Let me ask you a query: Are you genuinely excited to see Solo: A Star Wars Story? Is Rogue One your favourite Star Wars film? Do you really want to see precisely what number of Bothans died to convey us this info? In case you search your emotions, I’m betting the reply to all of those questions is “no.” To ensure that the franchise to reside, Star Wars needs to let the past die. Since 2015’s The Pressure Awakens, there was a model new Star Wars film yearly, one thing that may proceed till the inevitable warmth demise of the universe. And that’s tremendous. Paying a go to to the galaxy far, far-off is one in every of my favourite cinematic pastimes. However Lucasfilm’s incapacity to let go of acquainted faces, locations, and settings is slowly suffocating Star Wars with a Pressure choke of nostalgia. And that’s precisely what we’re going to speak about on immediately’s episode of The Dan Cave.
Since Could 25, 1977, we’ve spent a whole bunch of hours within the galaxy far, far-off. It’s an enormous, expansive house fantasy universe stuffed with alien races, interstellar battle, and limitless risk. But for practically everything of these 41 years, we’ve virtually singularly targeted on the exploits of the Skywalker household, their buddies, associates, and the villains with whom they cross paths. Realistically, we’re solely protecting a time span of roughly 60 years and following the adventures of the identical folks time and again. If we’re purported to be in a complete galaxy, then why can we solely spend time with Luke, Han, Leia and the gang? Particularly now that we’ve had not solely a core trilogy targeted on their characters, but additionally a prequel and sequel trilogy too. Maybe, it’s time to heed the phrases of the thiccest prodigal son within the galaxy: “Let the previous die. Kill it if it’s important to. That’s the one method to turn into what you have been meant to be.”
Although Kylo Ren’s phrases have been a bit extra nihilistic in the context of The Last Jedi, he makes an fascinating level. Accepting the previous and understanding it are important to informing the current and the longer term. Feeling beholden to the previous in a approach that hinders good storytelling, although, is a disservice to the narrative and the followers. Take a look at the much-maligned prequel trilogy. Have been they good films? Properly, it is dependent upon who you ask. On paper, the prequels are an excellent story, a chronicle of how the Chosen One, he who was purported to convey steadiness to the Pressure, was tempted by darkish powers and helped a Machiavellian madman plunge a galaxy into conflict and set up an autocratic nightmare regime. The best way they have been advised? Properly, let’s simply say that George Lucas most likely ought to have labored issues out with Marcia Lucas. It wasn’t till reveals like The Clone Wars and Star Wars Rebels that this time interval was meaningfully explored in a approach that George Lucas maybe initially meant: totally, thoughtfully, and with an eye fixed in direction of creating compelling tales inside an current framework.
Within the case of Star Wars anthology movies, although, Lucasfilm doesn’t simply settle for the previous; they’ve an unhealthy dependency on it. Living proof: Solo: A Star Wars Story, a.ok.a. the standalone film that no one requested for. Primarily as a result of it doesn’t stand alone. Slightly, it stands adjoining to the canon, related by unbreakable bonds of company concern and misguided fan service, current to fill in a niche no one was asking about. Have been you questioning how Han met Chewie? Did you crave solutions to how Han Solo made the notorious Kessel Run in lower than 12 parsecs? Do you give a womp rat’s ass if that Wookiee we see practically die on a space-train is definitely Chewbacca’s spouse from the notorious Star Wars Vacation Particular? Okay, possibly sure to that final one, however in any other case no.
Rogue One fares barely higher by giving us a largely brand-new forged of characters who’ve a connection to the bigger narrative we’ve come to know and love, however the stakes really feel nonexistent as a result of we already know their mission is profitable. You’ll be able to say that it’s in regards to the journey, not the vacation spot, nevertheless it’s exhausting to really feel actually invested within the journey when you realize that everybody on it’ll die after giving the world’s most essential USB drive to Princess Leia. Connecting A to C might be an fascinating train, however Rogue One‘s insistence on dredging up acquainted faces in technologically horrifying methods on the expense of character improvement, amongst different issues, hindered the story from attaining its true potential.
The Final Jedi, then again, is a wonderful instance of a Star Wars movie that embraces the previous whereas concurrently constructing one thing new, reasonably than treading water like so many Admiral Ackbars at so many Mon Calamari pool events. It’s on no account an ideal film, nevertheless it takes dangers with the present canon, subverting expectations and blowing up traditions in an effort to construct one thing new and move the torch to a brand new technology of characters. Saying that it killed your childhood or ruined Star Wars is an childish and admittedly insane factor to say. The one individual ruining your childhood is you and your incapacity to just accept that continuously revisiting acquainted floor is a creatively bankrupt endeavor that may drain the franchise of what made it so particular within the first place.
It’s straightforward to know why Lucasfilm has but to journey into the proverbial Unknown Areas of Star Wars filmmaking. We’re hooked on nostalgia, to feeling a rush of endorphins from recognizing a winking nod to one thing you realize and love. It’s like consolation meals. Whenever you strive one thing new, folks get scared as a result of it makes them uncomfortable by altering the deal. You’ll be able to pray they don’t alter the deal any additional, however that may be a idiot’s errand. Change is inevitable as a result of the choice is stasis, and stasis is demise. Filling in more and more granular gaps in current canon is a recipe for catastrophe. It’s the gradual demise of sinking into artistic quicksand that may result in Han Solo: The Tuesday Earlier than A New Hope being the very last thing we see earlier than we die.
So the place can we go from right here? Nerdist’s managing editor/our resident porg whisperer Amy Ratcliffe penned an excellent essay explaining that for Star Wars’ next trilogy–which purports to “introduce new characters from a nook of the galaxy that Star Wars lore has by no means explored earlier than”–Rian Johnson and his collaborators ought to look to the distant previous or the distant future. Take us to the early days of the universe for a primordial battle of excellent and evil between Jedi and Sith; present us the Outdated Republic, a sprawling house opera set 1000’s of years up to now; or take us properly past the occasions of Episode IX and allow us to see how the consequences of the Skywalker Saga have rippled all through the ages. Give us experiments in style like those Eric Diaz urged in his essay on Nerdist. Are you able to think about if we received a film model of what Star Wars 1313 was going to be–a gritty crime drama set in an underworld stuffed with employed assassins, bounty hunters, and saboteurs? Or a straight-up horror movie set within the Outer Rim? The thoughts reels on the risk and that’s the true spirit of what Star Wars is all about: elemental, mythic storytelling set in a faraway land of infinite hope and risk. To disregard that may be a shortsighted mistake. It’s worse than Jar Jar Binks delivering 50 kilos of extraordinarily coarse sand to your door.
However what do you suppose? Do you agree that Star Wars must let go of its previous? The place do you need to see Star Wars go from right here? Let me know within the feedback beneath.
- Need to watch The Dan Cave earlier than anybody else? Join Alpha and get it 48 hours early!
- Don’t miss a single episode of The Dan Cave! Subscribe to this playlist.
- Uninterested in getting kicked out of eating places for being topless? Purchase a The Dan Cave t-shirt!
Dan Casey is the senior editor of Nerdist and the creator of books about Star Wars and the Avengers. Comply with him on Twitter (@DanCasey).
THE BIGGEST MOVIE NEWS RIGHT NOW