Nicholas Kamm / AFP / Getty Photos
Millennials could quickly yearn for the times when our breakfast habits might launch a thousand thinkpieces. The oldest of us at the moment are exiting the coveted 18-34-year demographic, that means our days because the darlings of entrepreneurs and chin-scratchers in all places are numbered. The youth tradition business is already shifting on, shifting its consideration to the post-millennial cohort, at present nicknamed “Gen Z.”
The worst instance of this in current reminiscence was Have Smartphones Destroyed a Technology?, a very panicky Atlantic cover story by psychology professor, company advisor, and onetime millennial-whisperer Jean M. Twenge. The Atlantic has a specific affinity for this sort of fashionable worrying dressed up as somber big-think — keep in mind Is Google Making Us Stupid? — and Twenge delivered it in droves right here, arguing that the time right now's teenagers spend alone with smartphones is poisoning them ceaselessly.
Twenge has been on the youth-scare beat for some time, and it’s notable that she has now turned to post-millennial fearmongering. I first encountered her work again within the mid-2000s, across the time when Twitter was launching and Time journal was declaring us all “Person of the Year.”
Her first main foray into millennial thinkery was her 2006 e book Technology Me: Why As we speak's Younger Individuals Are Extra Assured, Assertive, Entitled—And Extra Depressing Than Ever Earlier than. Twenge expanded on the theme in 2009 with The Narcissism Epidemic: Dwelling within the Age of Entitlement.
These books pandered to the identical complaints outdated folks have been making about younger folks since time immemorial, with simply sufficient techno-scare to make them appear contemporary and related. And so they established Twenge as a go-to quote manufacturing unit for cranky think-pieces on millennials, ushering in a brand new wave of hand wringing over our supposed shortcomings.
“Why are young adults so miserable?” requested a 2006 As we speak Present phase on Twenge's work. “Are social norms steadily unraveling?” wondered USA Today the identical yr. “Too much self-esteem can be bad for your child,” warned Alternet. Many teens are “overconfident” and “have wildly unrealistic expectations,” mentioned Fox Information. A 2009 ABC story on Twenge's work was headlined “Today's Teens More Anxious, Depressed, and Paranoid Than Ever.”
Twenge's “narcissism epidemic” narrative match completely with widespread confusion and fears relating to social media, know-how, actuality TV stars, modifications in parenting kinds, the disintegration of 20th century social establishments, and the altering workforce. It additionally echoed widespread criticism of the vanity motion, and the “participation trophy” fears that our cranky elders had already established in regards to the era then generally known as “Gen Y.”
However whereas consumer media ate up Twenge's sky-is-falling take on millennials, her friends in academia and the scientific neighborhood started to name bullshit.
Most of Twenge's assertions about millennial narcissism come from evaluating solutions given by them, Gen X'ers, and child boomers on an index known as the Narcissistic Character Stock (NPI). They're additionally peppered with anecdotes and doubtful insights drawn from all the pieces from the antics of Britney Spears and Paris Hilton to rising charges of plastic-surgery and school-shootings and the recognition of subprime mortgages.
There are some generational variations within the NPI. As an example, millennials are extra doubtless than boomers at their age to conform to statements like “I’m assertive,” “I prefer to take accountability for making choices,” and “I can dwell my life any method I need to.”
But Twenge takes these variations and teases out all types of unjustified conclusions.
Positive, millennials — primed our entire lives to worth self-worth and imagine within the validity of individuality whereas our grandparents have been taught to maintain their heads down and comply with the mainstream — could also be extra doubtless than our predecessors to determine with statements projecting confidence. We’re extra inclined to say “I’m going to be an awesome particular person” than “I hope I’m going to achieve success.” However there’s little proof this has unfavorable social results in mixture, or that it means millennials are extra liable to harmful pathological narcissism.
In actual fact, “developments in youth habits support the opposite conclusion,” as Neil Howe and William Strauss famous in a 2007 Los Angeles Occasions op-ed. As proof, they pointed to falling charges of crime, teen being pregnant, abortion, premarital intercourse, reckless driving, and drug use; rising charges of volunteerism; and analysis exhibiting that millennials get alongside higher with their dad and mom than earlier generations did.
In keeping with Jeffrey Jensen Arnett, a psychology professor at Clark College, “proof overwhelmingly exhibits that the vanity and self-belief of right now’s rising adults is just not 'too excessive' by any cheap reckoning.”
Writing within the journal Rising Maturity in 2013, Arnett cautioned Twenge's conclusions are additionally marred by her reliance on samples of school college students. Faculty college students “are usually not consultant of rising adults extra usually,” Arnett factors out. “They’re wealthier, whiter, and (by definition) extra extremely educated than their noncollege friends.”
It’s much more biased than it sounds. Twenge drew her conclusions from an much more rarified set inside U.S. faculty college students: those that attend four-year residential establishments.
However even when we take Twenge's knowledge at face worth, it's not essentially trigger for alarm — and should in reality signify excellent news, not a generational disaster. Many of the rise in alleged narcissism comes from women and girls, and girls have been, till a number of a long time in the past, typically taught that that pleasure and confidence have been unladylike. Is it actually a nasty factor that fewer millennial ladies really feel the necessity to downplay their very own strengths?
Finally, “the proof simply isn't there for an epidemic of narcissism or the rest” in Twenge's thesis, declared the Chronicle of Higher Education in 2010. “Social scientists would do properly to train a level of warning when decoding knowledge. Similar to with the little boy who cries wolf, individuals are certain to note too many phantom epidemics.”
If solely. Recollections are quick, and know-how modifications quick. If something, right now's accelerated information cycles and well-oiled outrage machine solely will increase the general public urge for food for phantom epidemics, which brings us again to this month’s smartphone freakout in The Atlantic.
Nicholas Kamm / AFP / Getty Photos
Nearly the entire issues with Twenge's millennial bullshit are on show in her somber evaluation of Gen Z, which she defines to incorporate these born from 1995 via 2012.
Maybe conscious that she wanted a brand new shtick to remain on the prime of the generational-guru sport, Twenge is now claiming that, round 2012, knowledge began exhibiting that “most of the distinctive traits of the Millennial era started to vanish” (she doesn’t say what knowledge exhibits this). And Gen Z isn't simply psychologically far-removed from millennials, she says — they spend their time in far alternative ways, too.
All of this she blames on smartphones — and it's a superficially interesting thought. Elementary college youngsters now have their very own iPhones. My greatest buddy's three-year-old can take a selfie. It's fairly attainable that rising up with smartphones and social-media could produce distinct psychological and social results.
However it's method too early to name them but. And Twenge's knowledge doesn't again up her try to take action.
As a substitute, she makes grave proclamations based mostly purely on anecdotes, correlations — corresponding to smartphone possession rising alongside greater charges of minor despair — and selectively wielded knowledge. As an example, she brings up a research suggesting extra unhappiness amongst eighth graders who’re heavy use social-media customers, however doesn't point out that the identical research discovered no impact for 12th graders.
Twenge “opinions solely these research that help her thought and ignores research that counsel that display screen use is NOT related to outcomes like despair and loneliness,” objected psychologist Sarah Rose Cavanagh in Psychology Today. And “nowhere is Twenge's bias extra apparent…than in some analysis that she truly does assessment however then casts apart as seemingly irrelevant to her thesis—specifically, the huge counter-evidence to the 'destroyed era' thesis contained in her headline.”
This counter-evidence consists of ample knowledge exhibiting that Gen Z, like millennials earlier than them, have far decrease charges of smoking, unprotected intercourse, automotive accidents, alcohol use, and teenage pregnancies. (“That is what a destroyed era appears like?” asks Cavanagh.)
As we speak's teenagers even have a decrease suicide charge than teenagers within the 1990s, and self-reported happiness levels among teens have held relatively steady since 1997. Neither reality matches the narrative of a era extra depressing than ever earlier than. As a substitute, Twenge ignores all of this and begins throwing in buzzwords like “cyberbullying” and “Snapchat” to elucidate the non-existent spike in Gen Z suicides.
Think about a type of examples: teenagers right now are going out unsupervised much less. There are explanations for this apart from teenagers being ruined shells of human beings — corresponding to elevated participation in extracurriculars and arranged actions — that might account for this.
However extra importantly, earlier generations didn't have a lot alternative however to exit in the event that they needed to do issues like socialize with a number of buddies or watch films. Now that teenagers can talk digitally or hang around collectively at house watching Netflix, does it actually counsel a destroyed era in the event that they select to do this as an alternative of hanging out on the native movie show?
Twenge even sees doom in teenagers right now holding fewer part-time jobs in the course of the college yr. However on the identical time, volunteering is up, as are instructional calls for. The minimal wage is greater, and there are tighter rules on teen working hours. Why ought to we lament, as Twenge does, a 50% drop for the reason that 1970s in eighth graders working for pay?
Twenge tells dad and mom one of the best factor they will do for his or her youngsters' well being and happiness is to make them put down the smartphones. I counsel it’s the dad and mom who ought to shut their browsers for a minute — at the least lengthy sufficient to cease studying panic items by snake-oil generational theorists. The children, by virtually all measures, are greater than alright.