It began off with a premise that, to be truthful, deserves dialogue and scrutiny. A Tumblr person, who refers to herself as ‘Feminist Chewbacca’ wished to find the basis causes of patriarchal domination in society, and turned to the English language to analyze the inherent sexism it allegedly comprises.
In as of late of pretend information and agenda pushing nevertheless, it has by no means been extra necessary to test your info. That is the place Feminist Chewbacca got here unstuck. Reblogging a submit she had discovered on Visual Poetry, she had most likely not counted on being fact-checked by an precise linguist. Her poorly chosen examples had been deconstructed one after the other, till she started to look reasonably fundamental, and a bit foolish.
A few issues to notice right here. Firstly, by introducing her submit with the phrases: “Males fabricated the concept that they’re the default intercourse to compensate for his or her organic inferiority and common superfluousness,” Feminist Chewbacca units a militant tone that isn’t going to endear her to many individuals, and he or she must have rock-solid arguments to reply to the inevitable assaults on her place.
Secondly, it’s in fact on no account clear that this ‘linguist’ is certainly certified or not, and his info additionally deserved to be checked. After some cursory analysis I can collect that whereas some claims maintain water, others are open to argument themselves. There may be actually extra to the difficulty, and Feminist Chewbacca is correct to shine a light-weight on it. She simply went about it within the flawed approach.
So what to take from this sordid affair? Nicely, I assume it’s simple to move off another person’s arguments as your personal, however at the least perhaps test if they’re factually right first. Additionally, in the event you start from an extremist place and with combating phrases, anticipate individuals to combat again. If they arrive armed with info and you might be simply regurgitating opinions that fit your political outlook, you might be simply asking to be made to look silly.
Scroll down to take a look at the way it unfolded beneath, and tell us what you assume within the feedback!
Tumblr person ‘Feminist Chewbacca’ picked up art work that resonated along with her beliefs, that sexism is rooted in language
Picture credit: Richard Tipping
However this linguist wasn’t having it, and wrote an in depth and certified response